Tag Archives: Sustainability

It’s not the size of the vessel that count, but how it is managed

If you are a fan of developing sustainable fishing, then super-trawlers are probably not something you smile about.  Take a look at the image below from the Greenpeace campaign against the Abel Tasman (FV Margiris) – the world’s second largest fishing vessel.  Weighing in at a some 9 ,500 GT, this trawler-come-factory ship invoked the anger of NGO’s and Australians (whose waters she was due to fish in) who saw the vessel as a huge threat to marine biodiversity.  A huge campaign ensued.  The battle lines drawn.  No super trawlers.  Not here.  Not anywhere.  Just last year, the Abel Tasman was banned from fishing in Australian waters for two years.  Victory for the NGOs.

But was it the right thing to do?

Fisheries scientists Dr Sean Tracey and colleagues from the Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, and the University of Tasmania, Australia challenge the idea that the trawler was inherently a ‘bad thing’.  They argue that the campaigns was biased, presenting an argument based on only the worst examples of trawlers over-exploiting fish and damaging the ecosystem.  What the campaigns and the public  forgot was the importance of scientifically backed active management.

It’s a good point.  So, can super-trawlers be managed to fish efficiently without destroying the marine ecosystem?

The article – published in Fisheries which is produced by the American Fisheries Society – is likely to inflame many readers, but it is certainly worth following it through to the end.  It is open access… here’s the link (page 345 – or the 7th page of the PDF document).

Assessing global marine biodiversity status within a coupled socio-ecological perspective

 How sustainable is our use of the ocean ecosystems?  That’s one question the ongoing project the ‘Ocean Health Index’ is trying to answer.  It’s an ambitious project, seeing to figure out just how well we are conserving marine biodiversity and ecosytems, and if our use of the resources the oceans provide is sustainable.

In a recent paper by Dr Elizabeth Selig and colleagues, the Ocean Health Index has been broadened to take into account social and ecological pressures that reduce biodiversity – including looking at the social and governance factors that might improve the situation.

The first bit of news from this paper isn’t great.  Overall the future for marine biodiversity isn’t as great as we might hope, but some countries are doing better at looking after marine biodiversity and habitats than others.  Well…looking at other research, that’s not really a surprise.  What is interesting however is that countries that scored well for their species didn’t necessarily do well on looking after marine habitats.

On the good news side, some countries like Canada, Australia, and Russia seemed to have improved the condition of the marine habitat within their EEZ (economic exclusive zone) since the 1980s.

It seems that having a high ‘Human Development Index’ score – a composite statistic of life expectancy, educational attainment, and incomes – does not necessarily correlate between any biodiversity score.  Interestingly though, there was a relationship between the ‘Human Development Index’ score and social/ecological resilience, suggesting that many less developed countries don’t have the effective governance measures needed  to maintain biodiversity.  This is a huge problem because effective governance is regarded as an essential tool for effective conservation of biodiversity and sustainable resource use.

The paper is open access so if you fancy having a look though yourself at what they found, and how they calculated various bits and pieces (including a good helping of supplementary information) you can find it here


Image:  Oyster harvesters in Arradon, France.  Credit Martin Selway/Flickr (CC BY-NC 2.0)